With better market visibility and a clearer view of its own performance, Otis Ford moved customer pay gross profit into the top 10% of Ford dealers, increased monthly repair orders and uncovered more than $1 million in additional annual profit opportunity.

 

Results at a Glance

Key Result Impact
Customer pay gross profit percentage Top 10% of Ford dealers
Monthly repair orders +78
Customer pay ELR $179 maintained
Warranty labor rate +$63.02
Annualized warranty labor revenue lift $654,625
Additional annual profit opportunity identified $1.14M

The Challenge: Grow Profitably Without Losing Volume

Like many dealerships, Otis Ford knew pricing decisions could improve profitability—but it did not want those gains to come at the expense of customer volume. Without clear market visibility, knowing where to adjust pricing and where to hold was difficult.

For 80 years, family-owned Otis Ford has served customers in Quogue, New York, on Long Island’s East End. Its service operation includes three advisors and 21 technicians, including mobile, supported by a hands-on management team.

Anytime we do change the door rate most customers don’t notice. But if you add $5 to the oil change package people lose their minds.

Market Intelligence Creates Pricing Confidence

Otis Ford had historically held off on some price changes out of concern about losing customers. With Dynatron’s virtual performance groups (VPG) and mystery shopping, the team gained a clearer view of how its pricing compared with other Ford dealers and local independent competitors.

I now have hard data that compares other Ford stores and various other competitors in the area to see where we stack up.

That market intelligence gave Otis Ford the confidence to see where pricing had room to move—and where it didn’t. In six months, customer pay gross profit percentage moved from average among Ford dealers into the top 10%. At the same time, monthly repair orders increased from 656 to 734 while customer pay ELR held at $179, also in the top 10% of Ford dealers.

 

Capturing More Warranty Revenue

With customer pay pricing performing in the top 10% of Ford dealers, Otis Ford turned to warranty labor. Using FileSmart, the dealership increased its warranty labor rate from $162.71 to $225.73—a $63.02 increase, or nearly 39%.

The result: an estimated $654,625 in additional annualized warranty labor revenue.

 

Finding the Next $1.14 Million

Six months into its work with Dynatron, Otis Ford sent its service manager and general manager to Dynatron’s two-day executive workshop to identify additional performance opportunities within the existing service operation.

They returned with $1.14 million in additional annual profit opportunity identified—without requiring a single additional repair order. The largest opportunity was tied to one-line repair orders, representing $544,000 annually.

We have the potential to realize $1.14 million in additional annual profit without increasing the number of ROs we run. It’s here already

The workshop also validated where Otis Ford was already performing well: op codes required almost no correction, and repair parts margin was 44.9% against a 45% benchmark.

 

The Performance Advantage

In six months, Otis Ford demonstrated that service growth and margin improvement do not have to be competing priorities. Better market visibility helped the dealership move customer pay gross profit into the top 10% of Ford dealers while increasing monthly repair orders and maintaining a top-10% ELR. FileSmart added an estimated $654,625 in annualized warranty labor revenue, and the executive workshop identified another $1.14 million in annual profit opportunity already within the operation.

 

About Dynatron Software

Dynatron is championing a new standard of Fixed Ops excellence for automotive dealerships. The company provides the industry’s only AI-powered Fixed Operations Data Intelligence Platform, designed to help automotive dealers drive profitable growth and Fixed Operations performance. Dynatron’s insightful solutions and unique market comparison data provide unmatched clarity into dealership Fixed Operations and enable dealers to better capture market demand, expand margins, and drive retention. Backed by a heritage of innovation and transformation in Fixed Operations, Dynatron is trusted by more than 4,000 North American dealerships, including 9 of the top 10 dealer groups.

About the Author

Picture of Cam Johnson

Cam Johnson

Sr. Manager, Product Marketing, Dynatron
Cam Johnson leads product marketing for the Dynatron Fixed Ops Intelligence Platform. He works directly with Fixed Ops leaders and their teams to share how dealerships use the platform to gain a performance advantage.

Cam has over 15 years of experience, 13 of them representing SaaS and automotive brands such as Cox Automotive (Dealertrack) and Salesforce. His work scaling innovative brands has received national recognition from organizations such as The American Business Awards, PR News, and Search Engine Journal.